Trending Games | Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn | Guild Wars 2 | EverQuest Next | EverQuest

  Network:  FPSguru RTSguru
Login:  Password:   Remember?  
Show Quick Gamelist Jump to Random Game
Members:2,920,689 Users Online:0
Games:760  Posts:6,312,244

Show Blog

Link to this blogs RSS feed

The Hub

To be honest, I'mnot sure but I have an idea i want to run with. The Idea is this: To write the first hand account of creating a true MMORPG 2.0. In a rapidly changing genre, something has been forgotten. FUN! as has something else. Role-playing. =)

Author: Amblin

The Cut & Thrust of it.

Posted by Amblin Wednesday February 13 2008 at 8:08AM
Login or Register to rate this blog post!

Well folks, I thought I'd post a quick blog during lunch to talk about combat in MMo's, specifically Age of Conan.

Most reader will already be used to the skill bar version of combat, prevelant in MMo's. While this suffices for most, it leaves me cold. I want real combat, with me at the helm, not taking a back seat to preloaded animations.

Now, AoC promises revolutionary combat, so called free form fighting. However a closer look at the released information and videos, so the same skill bar combat plus an added directional attack button.

This is a far cry from the original vison and has been changed to allow for the greater majority to get to grips with combat. Fine, no issue with that one.

However, the fundemental element missing from all combat in MMO's is choegraphy. By this I mean limits on movements and a system for controlled reaction and count-action for players. Currently there is too much freedom and this has created melee combat flows of stun, circle, circle, stun, circle, circle etc.

In PvP in AoC and most other MMO's combat is based on distance form the target and the direction they/you are facing. This is ok, until it's 2v1 or 3v1 etc. Then the single player is dead 99.9% of the time although they may not know it yet. The reason is because 1 player cannot position themselves adequately to properly defend themselves due to a badly designed freedom of movement system.

The very thing I beleive most players want is great looking, exciting combat that has pace, flow and momentum, just like the movies. When you played swg, didn't you want epic saber duels ala phantom menace or return of the jedi? What you got in reality was constant circling and running away.

To achive a good, paced combat system requires control and limits, not just on skills, but movement. It is from the combination of movement and pacing of attacks that the dance of war is born.

Pace is important too, you should get the coice of how hard you attack, by adding momentum to attacks. To mush power and you over swing and allow the opposing player to dodge/counter etc. use too little allows easier parrying but opens up feints etc.

Also flow is something missing in combat. You know that in medievel time full plater wearer would fight for about 5 minutes on average then retire and another would take their place so they could catch their breath. Just the same, MMOs should have flow between the winning player in combat and like wise provide opportunites for the loser to regain the upper hand.

In AoC Prepare to be disapointed, combat has a few new buttons but it isn't a step forward, it's just a side-step to mediocrity.

Anyone that is trained in using weapons will tell you fighting is a dance, it has flow and timing and is all about control, something that must be added to any MMO combat system if players are to get the chance to really enjoy swashbuckling their way through the enemy.

What do you think?

jusomdude writes:

I'm glad to see something new and tired of people being spoiled about it. Sure people can have their opinions about it but no system is gonna please everyone. If they made it like you wanted there would be someone taking your spot to blog about how they don't like it. I havn't tried Conan combat but it looks pretty cool and anything closer to action type gameplay is good in my book.

Wed Feb 13 2008 11:29AM Report
so2404 writes:

aoc combat may not be the fluid move style combat, umm but either is real life combat. any step away from auto attack is a step forward not to the side. once consoles master fluid move style combat wait 10 years and it will be in mmo's but not any sooner. servers being the main issue. the "jump" test  so to speak, i jump and 1-3 sec later i jump on another screen can cause major issue in dodge /block/ parry combat

besides for true visual combat we need full control of are avatars and vr and envirmental staging(jumping off a wall to get to your opponents back for exp) is very far off 20 years or more for arcade. and 50+ for home consoles. the abilty just isnt there to ahve that kind of combat with out it fealing like bland button mashing at this point in time. one day but not yet

Wed Feb 13 2008 3:01PM Report
steuss writes:

I absolutely agree with you on this. Fighting is a Dance, and mmo's of today are completely unrealistic! Hell, they are even based on some ridiculous numbers and level systems? How freaking old are those concepts! They even have... CLASSES! AHHHHHHH!!!!

 

seriously, until we move away from tired and boring game fundamentals we aren't going to see any huge leaps in gameplay techniques. They'll keep pumping out the same crap they have until no one buys it, or a better selling WoW comes along.

 

I think your dream of this type of combat will really be realized in a fully immersive 3d enviroment where player movements will actually be translated into direct play movements.... ala .//hack, Kid Cameleon, etc.  Force feedback? neural jacks? who knows... but that is where our true gaming desire will be realized. Everyone wants to be Neo, while not necessarily also being Keanu.... /shudder.

Wed Feb 13 2008 7:10PM Report

MMORPG.com writes:
Login or Register to post a comment

Special Offers